I have the Fobus and the HP paddle style, the HP holsters are made by Galco, BTW.
The HP is a lighter weight leather than I expected, and has sort of a rough-out texture to it, but it fits well, and the price is unbeatable for any comparable holster. Wears well, and carries a little high, as most paddles do.
I think the Fobus will last longer though, and it has adjustable tension, instead of a thumb-break strap.
He who smiles last....
Not anything to do with me,...but SWAGA referred me to it...and it is pretty funny: The Ballad of Ajole
17 HP's and counting.