[William Spitzer]

So from what i can tell from the dimensions on the HP site, the difference between the c9 and c9 with a compensator is .5" of the barrel. I assume in that half inch is where the compensator attaches. So, i know i can get a barely used c9 for a decent price, but i would really like the compensator, so would I be better off to just buy a new c9 with a compensator, or call hi point and see how much the longer barrel and compensator would be, and pick up the regular c9. Or am i just being picky and should forget about the compensator, get a good deal, and leave it alone. lol

 

[farmkid]

HP is not currently making C9 Comps, so the options are to find a used one, or to settle for a plain C9. Or contact HP to see if they can provide the parts -- good luck!

 

[FRED J WAHL]

Hey, Bill, first off, Welcome to the Forum!
I have two C-9s, and a 9mm H.P. Comp. and as far as the accuracy goes, they are all pretty much alike-- on somes days, one of them will kick butt, then on other days, one of the other ones will! (Couldn't be the shooter, right? Nah---) The Comp is a little more confortable to shoot, because of the extra weight, but I really can't tell much difference in recoil, among the three. It would be an expensive venture to have the longer barrel installed, (don't think H.P even does that--), it would be much cheaper just to get a new Comp, but I don't know if H.P. even offers them, anymore-- (Suggest checking their Web Site--)
There are some issues with the Comp, that I have encountered, for instance the Compensator has a tendency to work loose after a while, and you have to retighten it on the barrel, with the Allan wrench they provide, (it is secured by a hollow head Cap Screw).
I haven't found the Comp to be that much of an advantage over the regular C-9, so I would suggest you pick up the used C-9, if it is a good deal, (I'd estimate around $125. should be about right, price wise, for a used one)
Let us know how you made out!
Cheers,
Fred (Honcho).

 

[William Spitzer]

HP is not currently making C9 Comps

looks like i'll get the regular c9 then, haha, i want to have my 995 and c9 in a hard case together with a bunch factory 10 round carbine mags, which if i understand correctly will work in the pistol

 

[William Spitzer]

The Comp is a little more confortable to shoot, because of the extra weight, but I really can't tell much difference in recoil, among the three

Kinda what i expected to be the case, the compensator didnt do anything much on my 995, except make it look awseome, lol, But i was after the longer, heavier front of the gun feel(plus i like the look), thank you both.

My dad is the possible seller of the hi point, so i can hopefully get a good deal

 

[JandN]

The 10 round carbine mags will work properly in the C9 if you fashion a sleeve to keep them from moving in the magwell and causing a malfunction. That is the same piece HP molded onto the 10 round pistol mags. You will be much better off getting a bunch of carbine mags and a bunch of pistol mags as they will function right. With a bunch of mags, I would seriously recommend the addition of a UpLULA mag loader, and save your thumbs some grief.
http://www.maglula.com/PistolMagLoaders/UpLULA9mmto45ACPmags.aspx
JEFF

 

[William Spitzer]

i have got to get one of those loaders, after just a few mags i dont even feel like shooting. So the carbine mags will have problem in the pistol?

 

[riverrat]

Has any one had a compensator break while firing? I fired about 8 rounds out of my C9 w/ compensator and when I check the gun out I found out the compensator had a piece broke off.

 

[ajole]

Got before and after pics? Unless the COMP was attached WAY wrong, it had a flaw in casting, or you threw the gun at a rock, there's just no way for that to happen.

Not calling you out, just asking for some help with figuring out what happened and how.

 

[peybella]

I would have to agree with the fellows. My wife and daughter both hate the compensator. They like a full barrel shroud and that's it. I put a shroud on mine with a compensator. Doesn't bother me but the girls both say it's a hindrance to them and they like the smooth forward picture through the scope or red dot. Wife has a low profile setup with a 10x30 scope and daughter a red dot on hers. I think it doesn't matter to me so much because of the scope I use. I must say that the clean look of my wife's 40 carbine beside of my 40 makes me want to get a full barrel shroud and get rid of the compensator.

 

[ajole]

What the heck? I really have NO clue what that was about, as I have NEVER been able to get a carbine comp to obstruct ANY of my scopes or other optics.


BTW, this is about the pistols.

 

[peybella]

Didnt say obstruct. Said hindrance. Just a piece of extra metal at the end that they worry about and are always aware of being there. They like the clean look with the scope and red dot. I wont comment again as I seem to be a hindrance. Sorry.

 

[ajole]

Didnt say obstruct. Said hindrance. Just a piece of extra metal at the end that they worry about and are always aware of being there. They like the clean look with the scope and red dot. I wont comment again as I seem to be a hindrance. Sorry.

No, I just misunderstood, please pardon me for coming on too strong, and keep being part of the conversation.

 

[peybella]

Kinda what i expected to be the case, the compensator didnt do anything much on my 995, except make it look awseome, lol, But i was after the longer, heavier front of the gun feel(plus i like the look), thank you both.

My dad is the possible seller of the hi point, so i can hopefully get a good deal

Thanks man - This quote is the only reason I mentioned the carbine. I was going to mention a broken compensator and have never had one on any of my HP pistols or Carbines. Did have one on my SKS once and it scared the crap out of me. I know - Off subject - But a 7.62x39 ball round hitting a broken compensator makes for a loud noise, sparks, the works. Found the bulk of what was left of the compensator down range in a gnarled mess. My point is - Just be careful. Make sure the compensator is seated to the limit groove and tight. Seems like if you can shoot a few mags through it, make sure it stays tight, you should be OK - be it pistol or carbine. Constant inspection with cleaning after use of course.