"Cheap" 1911 advice

Discussion in 'General Firearms Discussion' started by travis9mm, Jan 1, 2015.

  1. travis9mm

    travis9mm Member

    450
    1
    So im wanting to step into a 1911. Now before we start, my reasoning is my own. Ive loved these for as long as I can remember. While there are many guns id love to own a 1911 is head and shoulders above these. Im wanting a low level entry model. Im contemplating-

    Rock Island
    Armscor
    Citadel

    Im wanting something mil-spec so I can find triggers, grips, and sights thatll fit. My next debate is

    Full size
    Commander
    Officer

    Im pretty sure ill go with a .45acp. Again with fitment of after market pieces.

    Does anyone have any experience with the listed brands? Or have another idea of the sub $300-500 range?

    Thanks!
     
  2. greg_r

    greg_r Lifetime Supporter

    9,094
    6,727
    Citadel. Armscor, and Rick Island Armory are all the same gin. All made by Armscor. They are good guns. As far as size, what are you going to do with it? I think full size, for general use, and I sometimes carry my full size also, but for carry the commander is quite a bit smaller.
     

  3. Johnny_B_Goode

    Johnny_B_Goode Member

    218
    1
    You can get a used Glock or M&P 40 cal with night sights that you can easily carry for less than an AMSCOR 1911. Check out Buds gun shop under police trade ins. If you like revolvers get a Model 10 with a round butt and have a 3" barrel installed. I carried a model 10 in my pocket for years. I bought it at a NOPD surplus auction for $52.
     
    Last edited: Jan 1, 2015
  4. MaryB

    MaryB Supporting Member

  5. Bull

    Bull Just a Man Supporting Member


    You miss the part where he said he wanted a 1911?..... Not something else?
     
  6. travis9mm

    travis9mm Member

    450
    1
    Just so everyone knows, a 1911 is the ONLY weapon im currently interested in buying. Period. lol itll be my carry gun.im a bigger guy so concealing isnt an issue. I have a conceal holster already for a full size 1911. I knew they were all made by the same company but prices deflect each other. Ive seen some ads for the ati officer size for $349 but im just not sure howd id like such a small .45. My buddt has the xdm? And its waaaay too snappy. I hate it. But im thinkin an all steel .45 may not be so bad.
     
  7. Fracman

    Fracman Member

    918
    468
    Full size 45 for you first 1911
    Buds is has a rock island for $421
    I have only shot the 22tcm 9mm rock seem to be a fine gun
    Buds also has a bunch of iver jonsons and girsan 1911s which I have never held or seen.
     
  8. RugerFan

    RugerFan Member

    178
    3
    I like my C9, BUT by far my favorite gun is my Ruger SR1911. New it is not in your price range, but I've seen it used for $500. I have a full size in .45 ACP. Love the 1911!!!
     
  9. Everybody I have talked to are extremely happy with their Rock Islands. Not positive but I believe most budget 1911's have a cast frame. The high end lines have forged frames, I have a essex frame(cast) and it has held up with thousands of rounds. I do not shoot +P in it though.
     
  10. ajole

    ajole Supporting Member

    35,324
    12,156
    NE Utah
    Seriously? A used Glock over a new 1911? When the guy specifically said he wants a 1911?

    Sheesh.:cool:

    It's hard to go wrong with any of the Filipino guns.

    There's more than a few RIA 1911's on Gunbroker, under $500 shipped. Buds does too.
     
    Last edited: Jan 2, 2015
  11. Think1st

    Think1st Supporting Member

    9,041
    2,602
    Florida
    I've only had Springfield Armory 1911s, so I can't comment on the brands you have listed, but as far as size goes, I'll offer my $.02. The full size model will offer you more sight radius and a smidgen more velocity, as well as more readily available parts in the future. The narrow profile of the 1911 will help you keep it flat and avoid printing, while also keeping it more comfortable for IWB carry. With that in mind, the shorter models will only offer an advantage if you are smaller in stature or need to dress very lightly. Generally, the 1911 seems to hide well, regardless of length in most cases.

    One last thing--the full size model will be much more fun to shoot in the long run, and it will be more versatile.
     
  12. Grant

    Grant Member

    399
    7
    RIA is great. Consider the Taurus, possibly the best for the $ 1911.
     
  13. lklawson

    lklawson Staff Member

    See if you can find any LGS with a NIB Remington R51, buy it, then exchange it at Remington for the R1. ;)

    Peace favor your sword,
    Kirk
     
  14. you should submit that to the life hack website :p
     
  15. jcwit

    jcwit Member

    185
    0
    Check out all the pawn shops in your area.

    Now is a very good time to do that, folks needed money for Christmas.

    I picked up a like new Kimber a few years ago at a pawn shop for $350.
    Like new?? Didn't even have the idiot scratch! Came with the box and all papers, I'm the guy who mailed in the warranty.
     
  16. Fracman

    Fracman Member

    918
    468
    The Taurus has a bigger slide so it does not fit into must 1911 holsters
     
  17. greg_r

    greg_r Lifetime Supporter

    9,094
    6,727
    Don't know because I have not handled one, but I hear the Tisas is a well made budget 1911 with a bad trigger.
     
  18. I have two 1911's. One is a GSG .22lr and one is a RIA 9mm tactical... I love my Rock!