I used the same product to try to blacken Bushman's handle as well. I used a scotchbrite pad to try to even out the brighter spots so that the aluminum black would take more evenly. It ended up kind of spotty on the edges regardless. I have mine saturated in gun oil now, hoping that once she cures by morning, the aluminum black coating looks a little better. I'll post again in the morning with results. When I've cold blued metals in the past, leaving it sit with gun oil on it really ends up with a nice cured finish. I'm hopeful that the oil will have the same effect on the aluminum black.
Note that the stuff wouldn't take whatsoever to Bushman's ring that he sells to hold down the front tab of the barrel rail when the stock front sight is removed. I think I'd need to really sand away on the ring to remove all the shiny parts before aluminum black would have any effect. That's too much work. I need to figure out some other way to make that ring black. (Thinking about trying a sharpie.)