The 1858 Remington has a very south frame because of the top strap. At this point, $250 would be fair for a NIB Pietta repo. Make sure there is no rust around the nipples, as I've seen supposed "new" BP revolvers have rust there. No, it wasn't "fired", but someone DID snap caps on the nipples, then not clean it. Lot of us here shoot these, so, if you buy it AND can find caps and/or powder, we can get you started on a whole new addiction.