Hi-Point Firearms Forums banner

Seriously thinking about 5.7

4512 Views 117 Replies 14 Participants Last post by  GrumpyOlMan
My "new job windfall" is going to buy my a new gun. I'm kicking around several ideas ranging from a lightweight .308 AR to a 1911 45ACP +P stoked with 450SMC. But the 5.7x28 is quite intriguing to me. I'm too cheap to ever buy a FN FiveseveN but the Ruger 57 was looking interesting, that is until I stumbled across the PSA 5.7 Rock.

So far, literally, every review I've found of it has been positive. Lower price, decent trigger, more capacity (23+1), more affordable mags, optics ready options...

OTOH, it's out of stock all the time and seems like there's only one company making OWB Kydex for it (WeAreNerd). And it's a "full size handgun" that is a tad longer than the G17 in OAL with more of a slide.

And 5.7 ammo ain't free. I like being able to reload to save money on practice ammo and, as @greg_r has noted, 5.7 ammo has a reputation, at best, for being errr... "fiddly."

But the round is flat shooting, claims 30% less recoil than 9mm, has what looks to me to be good terminal performance, is endorsed by people I trust as being very effective for social work, and, in the event that Russia invades, most of the ammo will penetrate NIJ II soft armor and about 1/3 of boutique commercial offerings will penetrate Level IIIA, and that's nothing to sneeze at.

...still, I'm pretty cheap.

Peace favor your sword,
Kirk
  • Haha
Reactions: 1
1 - 7 of 118 Posts
At the cost of new ammo, reloads are the best thing to compare.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I just put the basic Sig Romoeo zero on my P365, it was $120 at Sportsmans Warehouse. It's all polymer. They have a lot of RDS's on sale right now.

I ordered a Swampfox Justice for the XDM, about $200, I was looking at Holosun solar, but the were at least $80 more, and I can buy a lot of batteries for that.
  • Like
Reactions: 2


100%, BUY THIS ONE!!!!!!! Caldwell 122-560

BUT!!!!! It won't work if the pistol ejects too close to vertically. Unless you figure out a way to hang a baffle over your gun?

You can set it on a bench, mount it on a tripod, it works easily, for rifles or handguns, holds a pile of brass, doesn't mess with the cycling, and is easy to unload.

About $53 at Amazon, and worth it, especially if you do it BEFORE you've spent $100 on three other options that never quite work.

$45 before shipping at Caldwell Brass Catcher Heat-Resistant Mesh All Pistols & Rifles 122-560

$43.62 before shipping at CALDWELL BRASS TRAP PISTOL/RIFLE UPC: 661120225607
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
That's the one I have,, didn't work too well with the 5.7.
I was afraid of that. Guess you could go gangster style and angle the gun sideways?:ROFLMAO:

Or....you could put it on a tripod and angle the head so so it's OVER your gun.....might drop brass all over you though.
  • Haha
Reactions: 1
Running drills is why steel cased ammo is still popular. 👍
  • Like
Reactions: 1
I have the Swampfox Justice green dot on the XDM. About $200 on Amazon.
So far, so good.
I looked at the Holosun, mostly for the solar backup, and just decided that I could buy a lot of batteries for the cost difference.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Just to rub it in a bit....
$700 for a PSA Rock, with a Holosun 407 red dot, 2X 23 round mags, threaded barrel.

https://palmettostatearmory.com/psa...-holosun-407k-reflex-sight-two-tone-gray.html

See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
1 - 7 of 118 Posts
Top